No Saugerties Casino, Inc.

News Release

October 2006

 

THE TRUTH COMES OUT:

THE CASINO DEVELOPERS’ PLANS FOR THRUWAY EXPANSION

 

 

Several weeks ago, a representative of the Winston Farm’s owners notified the Town of Saugerties that Thomas and Paul Wilmot, the developers of the proposed Seneca-Cayuga casino, had withdrawn their option on the property. This is good news!  Up to a point.

 

To date, neither the developers nor the chief of the Seneca-Cayugas have said a word publicly. We don’t know if they’re moving on or if they’ve set their sights on another property in Saugerties. We don’t know if the Wilmots have transferred their allegiance and financial backing to another tribe that is not saddled with the legal roadblocks of the Oklahoma-based Seneca-Cayugas. We don’t know if the Wilmots are involved with the activity on Route 32 South, just across the Saugerties border in the Town of Ulster and within the Saugerties School District, where options on homes around the old IBM Recreation Center are being purchased and a casino is rumored. And we don’t know if another developer and tribe will pick up the option for Winston Farm and start the process again.

 

For these reasons, No Saugerties Casino will remain vigilant and pro-active in ferreting out information and ensuring that our community is kept abreast of what is going on.

 

Now, we have startling information on just how massive the changes would have been — and still could be —  to Saugerties had the casino proposal been successful. Under the Freedom of Information law, we asked the New York State Thruway Authority to give us information on any activity regarding proposed changes to Exit 20. In response, we’ve received a set of maps, schematics and documents, dated March 2006, that the developers submitted to the Thruway planners – plans that lay out a scheme that would have urbanized a large portion of Saugerties and drastically altered not just traffic patterns, but the nature of our community. 

 

The plans would have made Saugerties the second largest interchange on the Thruway, with up to 14 lanes spilling out onto Routes 212 and 32-North and the Peoples Road area west of the Village. That’s only one less lane than the Woodbury Exit 15 toll exchange, the largest in the system, and twice as many lanes as Albany’s Exit 23, used heavily by commuters. It’s four lanes larger than the ten lanes of Exit 16 in Harriman. According to an on-line article posted by the Times Herald Record, 29,000 people a day pass through each of the Harriman toll plaza’s E-ZPass lanes and 13,000 people a day pass through the exact-change lanes.

 

In light of these figures, we see how seriously the developers were understating their plans and the impacts those plans would have, when they presented their proposal-brochure to the Town, Village and public. For example, while they stated that they expected to accommodate an additional 19,309 visitors to Saugerties each day, in fact, the projections they gave the Thruway show a casino, shopping and complex far, far larger than that – with four times the hotel rooms of Foxwoods, the country’s largest casino resort. Here’s what the documents show:

 

 

What the casino developers stated in their brochure

“Closest to our hearts is the central tenet to the Saugerties Entertainment Resort project: that we create a project that is in harmony with the pristine ecology and small-town, peaceful lifestyle that characterize Saugerties and Ulster County.”  This is a direct quote from the brochure that was distributed by the developers, the Seneca-Cayuga chief and their PR people to the Ulster County Development Corp. and the media in June 2005 – the only casino document ever made public. It said the resort would include:

 

·          A 601,900-square-foot hotel with 900 luxury suites and rooms

 

·          512,000 square feet of retail shopping

 

·          6,000 parking spaces

 

·          19,309 daily visitors

 

 

What the developers told the state

 

Resort Hotels ~ The documents reveal plans for three resort hotels with a total of 2,250,700 square feet and 5,900 rooms. Resort One was to have 1,400 rooms, Resort Two 2,500 rooms, and Resort Three 2,000 rooms. 

 

To put this in perspective, the Hudson Valley Resort in Kerhonkson has 275 rooms, Mohonk Mountain House in New Paltz has 266 rooms, Foxwoods Casino has three resort hotels with a total of 1,416 rooms, and Mohegan Sun Casino has 1,200 rooms.

 

Retail ~ Documents show the developers planning a one-million-square-foot retail shopping mall within the confines of the sovereign nation casino complex. In comparison, the Hudson Valley Mall, the largest shopping area in Ulster County with over 70 stores and restaurants and a 12-screen cinema, is 765,000 square feet. The obvious result would be a siphoning off of retail customers from local businesses and the Hudson Valley Mall.

 

Daily casino traffic ~ The developers’ brochure stated that the casino complex would receive 19,309 visitors a day, but the trip generation matrix they submitted to the Thruway shows that figure to be a grossly deceptive understatement. For a morning peak hour—just one hour—the developers predict 1,652 cars going into the complex. For an evening peak hour, they predict 2,689 cars going in. On a weekend, the number jumps to 4,954 cars going in during a single peak hour. Of note is that 3,764 of those daily peak car trips were destined for the retail center.

 

 

What they wanted for the Thruway and surrounding roads

The developers proposed several alternatives for Exit 20:

 

Alternative 1

Change the northbound toll plaza leading to Route 212 from three to eight lanes. Relocate the Thruway bridge abutments, widen the bridge and Route 212 to six lanes. Change the current southbound toll plaza leading to Route 32 from three to six lanes with a six-lane road leading into Winston Farm. Add an additional Route 32 casino entrance and exit road on either side of the historic Wyncoop House. Make Route 32 North into a six-lane road from Route 212 past the Thruway and then five lanes to Mower Hill Road. Install two traffic lights at the casino and Route 32 intersections.

 

[To give you a sense of size, consider this: Exit 23 of the Thruway, which thousands of commuters to Albany use, is only seven lanes. The developer’s scheme of a total of 14 lanes would make Saugerties the second largest Thruway interchange in the entire system. The largest, the Woodbury toll exchange at Exit 15, is 15 lanes. This massive expanse of highway is not how our community would ever want to introduce visitors to “friendly, historic Saugerties.”]

 

Alternative 2R1

Remove the existing northbound toll plaza and ramps. Change Route 32 North into a four-lane road. Change the southbound toll plaza into six lanes with a traffic light on Route 32-North for entry to and exit from the casino. Build a new northbound Thruway exit with an eight-lane toll plaza. Build another four-lane bridge over the Thruway just south of Peoples Road, with extensive ramping looping through many properties into a new eight-lane toll plaza to be built on property between the self-storage facility and Casa Blanca Realty on Route 32N. Construct a new six-lane road leading from the toll plaza into Winston Farm, just south of Mowers Hill Road.

 

Alternative 2R2

Maintain the existing northbound Thruway exit and plaza. Change the southbound plaza into six lanes with a four-lane road leading into Winston Farm. Make Route 32-North a four-lane road with two stop lights between Route 212 and Mower Hill Road. Build a new eight-lane Exit 20B plaza for northbound traffic between Route 212 and Peoples Road. Build a new four-lane bridge over the Thruway with a six-lane road going directly into Winston Farm.

 

Alternative 3

Close both the north and south Thruway exit and entrance ramps. Build a new Exit 20 plaza. Make northbound traffic exit the Thruway north of Peoples Road and west of the railroad tracks, cross a new four-lane bridge over the Thruway, and join up with the traffic exiting the Thruway from the south. The traffic would cross Peoples Road and enter a 12-lane toll plaza on property west of the log home business. Casino traffic would continue onto a new four-lane bridge over Route 32 between Mower Hill Road and the gas station next to the Wyncoop House. There would be two traffic lights and a ramp system for traffic going north or south on Route 32.

 

In conclusion

We urge our neighbors in the Town of Ulster to learn from our experiences and to demand answers about what’s being planned in the northern section of their town. Whoever is buying up the options there is demanding secrecy, and that’s definitely not a good sign – as we now know from experience.

 

 

 

Return to Home Page